Many Miami residents are snowbirds, wintering in South Florida and summering up north, or holding homes in two states at once. Living across state lines creates a planning question other people never face: which state’s law governs your estate, and how do you avoid probate in two of them? Comparing the strategies makes the path clearer.
Domicile: The Decision Behind Every Other Decision
You can own property in many states, but you have only one legal domicile, your true permanent home. Establishing Florida domicile matters because Florida has no state estate tax and no income tax, while your northern state may have both. Snowbirds who want Florida treatment typically file a Florida Declaration of Domicile in Miami-Dade County, get a Florida driver’s license, register to vote here, and spend the majority of the year in the state. The contrast is stark: a high-tax home state may aggressively claim you as a resident if you leave the question ambiguous.
The Two-State Probate Problem
If you die owning real estate in both Florida and another state, your estate may face primary probate where you are domiciled plus ancillary probate in the other state to clear title to the out-of-state property. Two probates mean two sets of court proceedings, two timelines, and added cost. Avoiding that duplication is often the central goal of a snowbird’s plan.
Will-Based Plan vs. Trust-Based Plan
A Florida will (section 732.502) is valid and economical, but a will does not avoid probate, and for snowbirds it can mean probate in each state where real property sits. A revocable living trust (Chapter 736) is the workhorse for dual-state owners: by transferring both the Miami home and the out-of-state property into one trust, you can avoid probate in both states and let a single successor trustee administer everything privately. The trust costs more to set up and requires retitling each property, but for two-state families it usually does what a will cannot.
The Florida Home and Homestead
Your Miami residence may qualify for Florida’s homestead protections (Article X, Section 4), which shield it from most creditors and limit how it can be devised if you have a spouse or minor child. Snowbirds claiming a different state as domicile should understand they generally cannot also claim a Florida homestead exemption, so domicile and homestead decisions must line up. A Lady Bird deed can pass the Florida home automatically at death and keep it out of probate while preserving homestead during life.
Documents That Travel
A durable power of attorney (Chapter 709) and a health care surrogate designation should be drafted to work in both states, since a medical emergency could happen in either location. Many snowbirds keep coordinated documents so a hospital up north and one in Miami will both honor their agents.
The Bottom Line
For snowbirds, the comparison usually favors a Florida-centered, trust-based plan: clear Florida domicile, a revocable trust holding property in every state, and portable incapacity documents. That combination captures Florida’s tax advantages while sidestepping double probate.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Dual-state planning is nuanced, so consult a licensed Florida estate planning attorney (and counsel in your other state when needed) before acting.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.
